PHANTOM EMPIRES
  • MOVIES
  • OLD TIME RADIO
  • US TV
  • UK-TV
  • MOUNTIE PULP!
  • BOOKS
  • ARTISTS
  • ALMANAC
  • My Fiction
  • contact

A Rasputin Two-fer: Rasputin and the Empress (1932) & Nicholas and Alexandra (1971)

5/19/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
What person even slightly interested in history doesn't know those eyes?   Burning and possessing,  they drill into one's guts,  those eyes of Grigori Rasputin,  known as the mad monk.  To some he was a saint;  his wife loved him dearly,  and for years after his death she extolled his virtues,  even going so far as to have tolerated his many sexual excesses with other women.  To others he was a vulgar, drunken pig;  in still-existing audio interviews, he was described as loud, filthy and rude,  the kind of man who would eat greasy meat with his hands, and then pat a nicely dressed person on the back.  To others he was the most dangerous man in Russia,  whose affecting gravitas held the Romanov Tsarina (and thus the Tsar) under his control.

In reality Rasputin was never a monk.  He was an itinerant Siberian peasant,  a wandering proselytizer, well-versed in biblical knowledge, considered by many to have psychic powers, as well as the ability to heal illness.  It's the last quality that brought him to the the Romanovs.   The Tsar's son,  Alexei, still a young child, was a hemophiliac;  after a series of helpless doctors and even more useless faith healers,  Rasputin came and healed the boy,  using only (by his declaration) prayer.  From that moment on,  until his murder by poison, gunshots and drowning (apparently he was very difficult to kill),  a small part of the destiny of Russia was in his hands.

There have been a great many films about this odd figure,  but for the Great Villain Blogathon I'll be presenting a two-fer;  of all the films I've seen on the subject,  these two are my favourites by far.   The first of the two-fer is the 1932 stunner Rasputin and the Empress;  it shines for so many reasons, not the least of which is that it stars the entire Barrymore family,  John, Ethel, and Lionel,  in their only film together (although John and Lionel had appeared together that same year, in the classic Arsene Lupin).   This is very much an old school film in every sense.

Picture
Made just a few years after the advent of sound films,  the aesthetic of this movie is still part of the silent film universe;  the use of shadow,  full-room staging, and broad hand and facial gestures are all the stuff of silents, and they really work here.  Of course,  the Barrymores were all accomplished actors by this time (one of the reasons that they're not that well known today),  so they really shine on this artistic borderland.  There are so many visually stunning scenes that it's easy to forget that there's a story sometimes.  I get lost in an image from time to time,  and I find myself pausing the player in order to enjoy them.

Rasputin and the Empress, as the title implies,  really focuses on establishing the relationship between Rasputin and the Tsarina's fears and obsessive love for her child.  There is some pomp and circumstance,  but most of the story revolves around the basic Rasputin story:  sick child, worried mother, faith healer,  suspicion, jealousy,  and finally, murder.  The politics of the story are certainly there,  but they're all conspicuously placed in order to grease the narrative wheels.   In this stripped-down state,  Rasputin's intensity is in sharp focus;  I could really feel why the people around the Tsar felt that he needed to die.

Picture
Lionel Barrymore's Rasputin is a confidence trickster.  He heals Alexei with hypnosis,  going as far as to dangle a spinning pocket watch in front of the boy's wide, blank stare.  Rasputin here is always thinking,  always shifting,  controlling every situation with a silent glare or a harsh outburst;  his glare sees all, and everyone around seems to know that.

Barrymore here is very much like he was as Mr. Potter in It's a Wonderful Life.  This Rasputin is always the most intense figure in the room,  and you can see why the family were taken over by him.  Barrymore's ability to mitigate the overwhelming effect of extreme facial expressions (of which there are many here) by longer movements and changes of body position, is really masterful.  He's always moving,  but somehow he still seems to be a moody, imposing character, which I find impressive.

Overall, Rasputin and the Empress is a must-see for lovers of early sound pictures.  It may be more of a hardcore film-lover's movie than something for more casual watchers,  but I think that silent movie folk will dig right into it's stark and broadly expressive style.

Picture
The first thing that I'll mention about the 1971 historical epic Nicholas and Alexandra is the cast.  Any fan of UK telly will die when they see some of the names here:  Michael Jayston, Lawrence Olivier, Tom Baker, Ian Holm, Julian Glover, Timothy West, Michael Redgrave,  Brian Cox, and Maurice Denham...need I say more?  

They were really going for an epic with this one, and if it had been made ten years earlier, alongside classic monsters like Lawrence of Arabia and Doctor Zhivago,  I think it may have worked a bit better and hit a little harder.  By the early 70's, epic movies of this type were waning,  and to make it work must have been a bit of a struggle.  As it stands,  this is still a very good movie; it juggles many different levels,  and overall,  it does it very well.   That's the biggest contrast between Nicolas and Alexandra and Rasputin and the Empress.  Between the two films,  this is the more political and multi-storied;  we see the politicians in the Duma (the Russian equivalent of a Parliament) fighting for democracy against the Tsar's wishes,  we see peasants being brutalised (with the expected hatred in their hate-burning eyes),  we see Lenin,  we see Trotsky,  and we even see a young Josef Stalin,  all plotting the downfall of the dynasty that had so poorly managed the business of the people.

Picture
Tom Baker is an excellent choice for the mad monk.  The same oddness and unpredictable charm that makes his Doctor Who so excellent and memorable  combines with a kind of crazed darkness, and it makes for some great watching.  He comes off as a highly amused vampire,  moving from neck to neck,  looking for the juiciest artery.  Apparently there had been plans to cast Peter O'Toole as Rasputin (and Vanessa Redgrave as Alexandra),  but limits on the budget forced the producer into less exalted levels.  I consider that a stroke of good luck.  While I like O'Toole,  especially during this period,  I think Baker is the better choice...in spite of the possibility that it may have effected the longevity of the film overall.  In any case,  he was proposed for the role by Lawrence Olivier,  so who needs O'Toole anyway, wot?

What struck me most of all about Nicholas and Alexandra, is that, unlike the equivalent British films (and telly shows) about royalty,  there is nothing grand or sexy about the majestic lives of these rulers.  There are very few dramas, even in Russia,  that portray the lives of the old Russian aristocracy without an underlying darkness.  History, as they say,  is written by the victors,  and in Russia, the royals...lost.  Nicholas and Alexandra really tried to mix in a glamorous love story between the titular twosome,  but for any reason other than context,  it failed to draw me in.  To be honest,  the only truly powerful character in the entire movie is Rasputin himself,  and I think that,  as in reality, was the reason that he had to die.

Power is for the powerful...not for hedonistic holy peasants.

I would really recommend this movie to people who love to watch good actors doing what they do best.  The plot is a little uneven,  but the quality of the filming,  sets, and costuming balance out whatever the story lacks.

As a side note,  here are a few of the legion of actors that have played the so-called mad monk to greater or lesser degrees of success:  Conrad Veidt in Rasputin, Dämon der Frauen (1932),  The Suspense TV episode The Black Prophet with Boris Karloff (1953), the over-the-top Christopher Lee in the Hammer film Rasputin, The Mad Monk (1966), Aleksey Petrenko in the maniacal Russian production Agoniya, and two more television efforts: Alan Rickman in Rasputin (1996), and Gérard Depardieu in the French production Raspoutine (2011).    I'd really love to see the Veidt version!
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
To be honest, this is a bit of a trick review.  The point of this, for the Great Villains Blogathon, was to present a film or two that featured a fantastically villainous figure;  I've thus far focused on the amazingly dark character of Rasputin, for seemingly obvious reasons.  The true villain of the story,  to me,  was the Tsar himself.  The decadent excesses of the Romanoff family (contrasted against the most extreme poverty imaginable), the vicious and merciless treatment of the Russian people (Bloody Sunday and the Khodynka Tragedy), Anti-Jewish pogroms, the losses in the war against Japan over Korea,  the incompetent management of the first world war, all leading to his execution by the Bolsheviks, who, in their Soviet incarnation, ruled the Russian people with an iron hand for the better part of a century. By comparison, the manipulative debaucheries of Grigori Rasputin seem like kid stuff.  It's no surprise,  at this point, that both the films that I've reviewed here end with the execution of the Tsar,  his family, and household staff.

I recall a scene near the end of Doctor Zhivago, in which the soldiers, battered by the brutalities of WWI trench warfare, were marching toward home, revolution, and true change.  There was a determination in their eyes,  and nothing,  including mass murder, was off the table to make that change happen.
That determination,  the motive force of the Bolsheviks, was born in the actions of the Tsar...the true great villain.
Picture
Picture
The Real Tsar
Picture

Picture
_This is my entry in the great Villain Blogathon,  hosted by Ruth, of Silver Screenings,  Karen, of Shadows & Satin, and Kristina of Speakeasy.  Click on each of their names to check out their pages,  and click on the banner to the right to see some great villains in film on many other killer blogs!

0 Comments
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Latest Reviews
    (click to visit)

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Classic Movie Blog Hub Member

    MOUNTIE FILMS.pdf
    File Size: 73 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Here is my (ever-growing) list of Mountie movies and serials!  Enjoy!

    Upcoming Events


    Cool Blogs
    STALKING MOON
    Classic Film & TV Cafe'
    MOVIES SILENTLY

    CAFTAN WOMAN
    RIDING THE HIGH COUNTRY

    SILVER SCREENINGS
    SHADOWS & SATIN
    SPEAKEASY
    LAURA'S MISC. MUSINGS
    LADY EVE'S REEL LIFE
    They Don't Make 'em Like they Used to
    SILENTOLOGY
    Pre-Code  Film
    SILVER SCENES

    Thrilling Days of Yesteryear

    Mike's Take on Movies

    THE LIST

    All
    13 Assassins
    15 Post 1979 Films
    5 Films
    9 Hours To Rama
    Adventures Of Tartu
    A Heidi 2-Fer
    Alan Ladd
    Al Pachino
    A Man Called Horse
    Anthony Hopkins
    A Patch Of Blue
    Audie Murphy
    A Yank In Libya
    Barrymore
    Barry Sullivan
    Basil Rathbone
    BIRTHDAYS
    BLOGATHON
    Bogdan Stupka
    Breezy
    British Empire
    Buck Jones
    Buffalo Rider
    Caesar The Conqueror
    Cameron Mitchell
    Caryl Of The Mountains
    Chambara
    Chinatown
    Cisco Kid
    Claudette Colbert
    Cliff Edwards
    Clint Eastwood
    Colossus: The Forbin Project
    Come Next Spring
    Cowboy Motorcycles
    Dana Andrews
    Dan Haggerty
    Deborah Kerr
    Dick Powell
    Django
    Duncan Reynaldo
    Dustin Hoffman
    Eleanor Hunt
    Errol Flynn
    Faye Dunaway
    FILM BLOGGERY - Notes
    Foreign Legion Films
    Fort Vengeance
    Francis Sullivan
    Francis X. Bushman Jr.
    Franco Nero
    Fred Williamson
    Gary Cooper
    Gene Hackman
    George Hilton
    Giants Of Rome
    GLADIATORS SEVEN
    Go-Get-em Haines
    Gregory Peck
    Guy Rolfe
    Haldane Of The Secret Sevice
    HAMMER FILMS
    Harry Carey Jr.
    Harry Houdini
    HEART OF THE NORTH
    Hollywood Chess
    Horst Buchholz
    Humphrey Bogart
    Jack Nicholson
    James Craig
    James Oliver Curwood
    Jim Brown
    Jim Kelly
    Jimmy Stewart
    John Carradine
    John Huston
    Johnny Mack Brown
    John Wayne
    Jose Ferrer
    J. S. Casshyap
    Kay Lenz
    Ken Maynard
    King Of The Khyber Rifles
    KITOSCH
    Lee Van Cleef
    Leslie Howard
    Little Big Man
    Lon Chaney
    Love Affair
    MASSACRE TIME
    Mountain Man Movies
    Mountie Films
    MRS. MIKE
    My Man Godfrey 1957
    Nicholas & Alexandra
    NO!
    Nomads Of The North
    NORTHERN PURSUIT
    North West Mounted Police
    Northwest Rangers
    Oliver Reed
    Orientalism In Film
    Overland Red
    Peplums
    Pimpernel Smith
    QUO VADIS
    Rasputin & The Empress
    Reginald Denny
    Richard Harris
    Richard Harrison
    Rin-Tin-Tin
    Robert Donat
    Robert Morley
    Robert Ryan
    Ronald Colman
    Roy Rogers
    Sabotage Agent
    Serpico
    Shirley Temple
    Sidney Poitier
    SILENT FILMS
    Spaghetti Western
    Stranglers Of Bombay
    Take A Hard Ride
    Talbot Mundy
    Taras Bulba
    The Black Watch
    THE CANADIANS
    The Cossacks
    The Hunting Party
    The Life And Death Of Colonel Blimp
    The Mad Doctor
    The Prisoner Of Shark Island
    The Scarlet Pimpernel
    The Trap
    The Two Jakes
    Tim McCoy
    Tom Baker
    Tom Mix
    Top Ten Cowboys
    Tyrone Power
    Ukulele Ike
    Under Two Flags
    Victor McLaglen
    Warner Baxter
    We're In The Legion Now!
    Western Films List
    Westerns Through Time
    When Eight Bells Toll
    William Boyd
    Worst Film Accents
    Yankee Clipper
    ZARDOZ
    Казаки

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.